You graduated from a top law school. You've worked on complex matters, handled demanding clients, and developed the skills that make you a valuable member of your firm.
So why can something as seemingly straightforward as a job interview derail an otherwise promising career opportunity?
After years of helping attorneys navigate lateral moves, I've learned that the mistakes candidates make during interviews rarely have anything to do with their legal abilities.
More often, it's what they don't say, the assumptions they make, or the signals they unknowingly send.
And sometimes, the very instincts that make someone a successful attorney can work against them in an interview.
Here are six mistakes I see attorneys make, along with my advice for avoiding them.
1. Playing It Too Cool
Attorneys are competitive by nature. They're trained to negotiate, protect their clients' interests, and avoid revealing too much about their position.
Unfortunately, that mindset can carry over into job interviews.
Some attorneys worry that expressing enthusiasm makes them look desperate or weak. They believe that by playing it cool, they're maintaining their negotiating position.
But there's a difference between showing genuine interest and showing desperation.
I've seen highly qualified candidates lose opportunities simply because the interviewing firm wasn't convinced they wanted the job.
One candidate in particular stands out.
Years ago, I represented an attorney who was interviewing with several firms. After each interview, we'd debrief, and he'd enthusiastically tell me everything he'd learned and why the opportunity appealed to him.
Yet I kept receiving the same feedback from the firms: He doesn't seem interested.
I couldn't understand it.
Eventually, I discovered what was happening. Once he realized he liked a firm, he would jump ahead to picturing his life at the firm. Would his office have a view? Would he be going out for drinks with clients? The problem is that he was doing this during his interviews. He was so excited about the possibility of working there, that he appeared to mentally checked out of the rest of the interview, even though he was taking everything in!
In his mind, his interest was obvious. To the interviewers, his disengagement suggested exactly the opposite.
My advice: Don't make a firm guess how interested you are.
At the end of an interview, say something like:
"Thank you for taking the time to speak with me. Our conversation today not only confirmed my interest but enhanced it. When you mentioned [specific detail], that really resonated with me."
Be genuine. Be specific. And remember that expressing enthusiasm isn't a sign of weakness.
2. Failing to Answer the Unspoken "Why Us?" Question
Even when interviewers don't directly ask why you're interested in their firm, you can be certain they're thinking about it.
And "I'm looking for better hours" or "I'd like to make more money" aren’t the answers they're hoping to hear.
There's nothing inherently wrong with wanting better compensation or work-life balance. But if those are the primary reasons you give, you're sending a message you probably don't intend.
If money is your primary motivation, what's to stop you from leaving when another firm offers more?
Law firms invest considerable time and resources in recruiting. They want attorneys who plan to stay.
Similarly, criticizing your current firm rarely works in your favor.
Instead of describing everything you dislike about your current position, focus on what attracts you to the new opportunity.
Perhaps it's the firm's particular expertise, the opportunity to work more closely with clients, its reputation for mentoring associates, or the chance to develop a practice in an area that interests you.
Specificity matters.
Before an interview, after carefully reviewing the section about the practice you’ll be joining, I encourage every candidate to read the firm's entire "About Us" section, don’t just skim the attorney biographies.
Pay attention to how the firm describes its values, its clients, and its approach to practicing law.
This is how the firm presents itself to prospective clients and future colleagues. It's an excellent starting point for understanding what makes the organization distinctive.
Then be prepared to explain why those qualities matter to you.
3. Not Asking About the Path to Partnership
This is one of the mistakes that surprises attorneys when I point it out.
Even if you're not certain that partnership is your ultimate career goal, failing to ask about advancement can communicate a lack of ambition or long-term interest.
Partners have worked hard to achieve their positions. They naturally want to believe that the associates they hire –and mentor– aspire to similar professional accomplishments.
This is particularly important at smaller and midsize firms, many of which pride themselves on developing and promoting from within.
If you're a midlevel or senior associate, you should absolutely be asking about advancement.
What does the firm expect of attorneys who want to become partners? What does a Counsel title mean at this particular firm? What opportunities exist to develop client relationships and build a practice?
These are important questions, and asking them demonstrates that you're thinking seriously about your future.
For more junior associates, the conversation might sound different.
You might ask:
"What responsibilities would I have at my current level, and how would those responsibilities evolve as I become a mid-level and senior associate?"
I've spoken with associates who realize that the senior attorneys at their current firms aren't getting significantly more hands-on experience than they are.
That's a legitimate reason to consider a move.
The key is understanding whether the new firm can offer the professional development you're seeking.
And don't wait until you have an offer to find out.
4. Assuming Everyone Speaks the Same Legal Language
Here's something attorneys sometimes forget: terminology that means one thing at your firm may mean something entirely different somewhere else.
For example, an associate might describe themselves as "first chair" because they're the primary associate handling a case.
At another firm, "first chair" could mean serving as lead trial counsel.
Same words. Very different responsibilities.
When describing your experience, avoid relying on internal shorthand.
Instead, explain what you've actually done.
"I've served as the primary associate at my level on my matters" is much clearer than using a title that might be misunderstood.
And don't assume that your experience is identical to that of other associates in your class year.
In fact, I've found that attorneys are often more likely to undersell their experience than exaggerate it.
Talk about your accomplishments with confidence, but also with humility.
If you've had the opportunity to work directly with a partner on a significant matter, explain what you contributed and what you learned.
You can take pride in your work while acknowledging the team that helped you succeed.
The same principle applies when discussing a firm's policies and culture.
If your current firm has a three-day in-office policy that isn't strictly enforced, don't assume a prospective firm's policy will operate the same way.
Ask.
Assumptions can create misunderstandings that are entirely avoidable.
5. Forgetting That Body Language Is Part of the Interview
You can give thoughtful, intelligent answers to every question and still leave an interviewer with the wrong impression.
How?
By failing to communicate engagement.
Eye contact matters. So does posture.
Whether you're interviewing in person or virtually, keeping your head down or repeatedly looking away can make you appear uncomfortable or uninterested.
And remember, the attorneys interviewing you aren't just evaluating your legal knowledge.
They're imagining what it would be like to work with you.
They're also considering how you'd interact with clients, participate in negotiations, and represent the firm.
Can you communicate clearly and with conviction?
Do you seem comfortable engaging with other people?
Whether you’re interviewing in-person or virtually, I encourage candidates to lean forward slightly, make natural eye contact, and stay engaged in the conversation.
Of course, there's a difference between making eye contact and having a staring contest!
Another piece of advice: Be careful about commenting on someone's surroundings during a video interview.
During an in-person interview, asking about a photograph or memento on someone's desk can be a perfectly natural way to make a connection.
But when someone is interviewing from home, commenting on their personal belongings can feel intrusive.
Most importantly, remember to smile, laugh when appropriate, and enjoy the conversation.
A job interview shouldn't feel like an interrogation.
6. Ending the Interview Without Making a Connection
One of the most important moments in an interview comes when the interviewer asks:
"Do you have any questions for me?"
Please don't respond with, "No, I think you've answered all my questions."
Even if the conversation has been thorough, this is an opportunity to demonstrate that you've been listening and that you're genuinely interested.
Circle back to something the interviewer mentioned earlier.
For example:
"You mentioned that you're on the firm's Recruiting Committee. Is that something associates have an opportunity to participate in?"
Or perhaps you noticed on the firm's website that community involvement is important to its culture.
You might ask:
"I read that the firm supports several community organizations. Giving back is important to me as well. How does the firm decide which organizations to support?"
These questions do more than gather information. They help establish a personal connection.
And don't be afraid to acknowledge shared interests. If an interviewer mentions enjoying hiking and you enjoy it too, there's nothing wrong with asking about favorite trails.
You're meeting potential colleagues, after all.
What you should never do is end an interview with arrogance.
Statements like "I'm in demand, so don't let me walk out without an offer" are unlikely to create the impression you're hoping for.
Confidence is attractive. Entitlement isn't.
The strongest interviews end with both parties feeling that they've found someone they'd genuinely enjoy working with.
One Final Thought: The Little Things Aren't Always Little
Over the years, I've received feedback about candidates that had absolutely nothing to do with their legal qualifications.
An otherwise excellent attorney arrived looking disheveled.
Another wore clothing covered in pet hair.
One candidate wore so much cologne that the interviewer found it nauseating.
One issue that has gone viral is whether or not it’s okay to bring iced coffee into your interview. My view is that it is not. Ditto with bringing food into an interview. If you’re interviewing in-person, the firm will ask if you would like a beverage and they will provide a glass or cup for you.
If you’re interviewing virtually, don’t drink soda out of a can (even though we all do it), and be sure to use a glass or mug, not a “to go” cup. And don’t eat in front of your interviewer. If you are having a full round set of interviews, the firm will build in a break so you can refuel.
These may sound like minor details, but they can influence how someone perceives your judgment and professionalism.
Part of my role as a recruiter is preparing candidates for the questions they're likely to encounter, including the occasional question that comes completely out of left field.
But preparation also means helping attorneys recognize the small behaviors that can undermine an otherwise excellent interview.
When firms permit me to share candid feedback, I do. And candidates are almost always grateful to receive it.
Because when you know better, you do better.
Remember: You're Interviewing Them, Too
Here's what I wish every attorney would remember:
A job interview is a conversation, not an inquisition.
The firm is evaluating your experience, judgment, and potential. But you should be doing the same. Is this a place where you can grow professionally? Will you have opportunities to develop your skills, take on greater responsibility, and build the career you envision?
The best interviews aren't one-sided evaluations. They're conversations in which both parties discover whether there's a genuine fit.
So prepare thoroughly, ask thoughtful questions, express your enthusiasm, and don't forget to enjoy the experience.
After all, the goal isn't simply to receive an offer. It's to find an opportunity where you can thrive.
Considering a Lateral Move?
A successful career transition starts well before the interview.
I've spent decades helping attorneys navigate the lateral hiring process, from identifying the right opportunities, to preparing for interviews and evaluating offers.
If you're considering your next career move, I'd welcome the opportunity to have a confidential conversation about your goals, and how to achieve them.